layer hidden off the screen
UCSB English Department HomeUCSB English Department HomeUCSB English Department Home
 
 
The Culture of Information
ENGL 25 — Winter 2002, Alan Liu
Notes for Class 10

This page contains materials intended to facilitate class discussion (excerpts from readings, outlines of issues, links to resources, etc.). The materials are not necessarily the same as the instructor's teaching notes and are not designed to represent a full exposition or argument. This page is subject to revision as the instructor finalizes preparation. (Last revised 1/30/02 )



Preliminary Class Business

 Next lecture section


Previous lecture section Next lecture section

From William Gibson's Agrippa to Edward Falco's Self-Portrait as Child with Father

(Note: speed with which artists/authors are experimenting with new media)

The Process of Reading Gibson's Agrippa:

  • Section 1:

    • like flipping sequentially through a book

    • clarity of reference ("eerie Kodak clarity") balanced against allusive obscurity ("allusion" = indirect reference)

    Inside the cover he inscribed something in soft graphite
    Now lost
    Then his name
    W.F. Gibson Jr.
    and something, comma,
    1924

         .     .     .     .     .     .     .     .     .     .

    "Arthur on Dixie", likewise 1919,
        rather ill at ease.
    On the roof behind the barn, behind him,
    can be made out this cryptic mark:
    H.V.J.M.[?]

    "Papa's Mill 1919", my grandfather most regal amid a wrack of
    cut lumber,
    might as easily be the record
    of some later demolition, and
    His cotton sleeves are rolled
    to but not past the elbow,
    striped, with a white neckband
    for the attachment of a collar.
    Behind him stands a cone of sawdust some thirty feet in height.
    (How that feels to tumble down,
    or smells when it is wet)


  • Section 2:

    • What does Gibson mean that "the mechanism" is that which is "Forever / Dividing that from this"?

      • The passage means one thing when applied to the camera and photo album of Section 1

      • But it means something slightly different when applied to how we read Section 2, where the "new media" consciousness of the poem begins to show (digitization, modularity, variability, like re-compositing the pixels or re-ordering Photoshop layers)

    • Non-linear "jumping" or "linking" of Section 2 (e.g., ll. 105 ff.)

    • A new kind of clarity vs. obscurity, reference vs. allusion premised on lack of connected context (cf., Manovich on "modularity")

    • An updated "translation" of the beginning of Section 2:

      Original:

      The mechanism: stamped black tin,
      Leatherette over cardboard, bits of boxwood,
      A lens
      The shutter falls
      Forever
      Dividing that from this.

      Translation:

      The mechanism: injection-molded plastic,
      Circuits on chipboard, bits of silicon,
      A screen
      The mouse clicks
      Forever
      Linking that to this.


The Process of Reading Falco's Self-Portrait as Child with Father:

  • Your initial reactions to the work.

  • Reading of the first lexia (selfportrait.html): clarity yet obscurity of the links to the next lexias

  • The "meaning" of the work.
Previous lecture section Next lecture section


Previous lecture section Next lecture section

Overview of Hypertext and Hypertext Literature

Basic definition of hypertext: "lexia" and "link": George Landow, pp. 99, 100 [in Trend]

"Hypertext" was one of the first deployments of the "new media" (digitization, modularity, variability).

  • Practical level: from "Gopher" (U. Minnesota) to "WWW" (Tim Berners-Lee; NCSA and Mosaic browser)

  • Conceptual level: hypertext theory and literature:
A Timeline of the Origin of Hypertext Theory/Literature For a more detailed chronology, see Stuart Moulthrop, "A Subjective Chronology of Literary Hypertext"

(Other English Dept. courses on hypertext: Rita Raley, English 165LT, Alan Liu, English 165HL)

1940-50's -------------> 1970 -------------> 1980 -------------> 1990 -------------> 2000

WW II, Transition from Modernism to "Postmodernism"

Counterculture, Poststructuralism, Personal Computer Beginning of Hypertext Theory & Practice WWW
Bush, Borges Barthes, Derrida, Foucault, Deleuze & Guattari

Ted Nelson Michael Joyce
Jay Bolter
George Landow
J. Yellowlees Douglas
Stuart Moulthrop
Storyspace
Eastgate Inc.
                  M. D. Coverley
  • The rationalist bias toward "clarity" in early hypertext theory:

    • Vannevar Bush, pp. 10-11 [in Trend]
    • George Landow, pp. 104
Previous lecture section Next lecture section


Previous lecture section Next lecture section

Ed Falco's Critical, Reflective Use of Hypertext

"Self-Portrait as Child with Father" is a work of identity ("self-portrait") that purchases stunning clarity in its narrative vignettes at the cost of equally stunning obscurity.

A work that says that "new media" is not either more clear or more obscure, but clear and obscure in different ways that can be exploited to map out what is important to people.

The work's traumatic "clarity"—e.g., goat.html, fingertips.html

The work's obscurity—e.g., the image, link-sentence, and lack of context in fingertips.html

    How Falco is "allusively" obscure (some of the standard "problems" of hypertext literature):

The Problem of Navigation

Ever onward, or hub-and-spoke navigation?

Does one return and reread previously read lexia?

Does one's pattern of reading the work evolve or change?

What is the effect of chance on the reading experience?

What is reader "interactivity"?


The Problem of Closure

How is a sense of closure achieved by the reader?

  • closure = completion (hitting all the "lexia" or reading units)?

  • closure = mapping (systematic sense of the whole)?

  • closure = ?

Or is closure needed at all?


Narrativity

Is this work a "story" at all, or instead a "description" or perhaps "lyric"? [blocks.html] [figs.html] [jumped.html] [snow.html]


The Problem of Point-of-View

Who is speaking in children.html or beggar.html or quiet.html?

Why is this work a "self-portrait" of the child and not a "portrait" of the father? [child.html]


The Problem of Sentence Form

How does the hypertext medium influence the language of the work, and vice versa? [trouble.html] [lungs.html]

Falco on fiction and poetry [from interview]:

"I find hypertext to be closer to poetry. Since hypertext allows the reader to determine the sequence of words, traditional notions of narrative are impossible; as is any conventional sense of closure. Hypertext is interactive. In a very real sense, readers become writers, because they determine the structure of the reading experience: they decide where to start, what sequence of words to follow, and where to stop. Really, this is unlike any kind of traditional poetry or fiction, but it is closer to poetry in that the reader has greater responsibility for constructing the completed work and construing its meaning. A story with a beginning, a middle, and an end, is, on the surface at least, a simpler thing—and something hypertext can never be."

 

Previous lecture section Next lecture section


Previous lecture section Next lecture section

Olia Lialina's Critical, Reflective Use of Hypertext/ Hypermedia

Lialina's influence on new-media/hypertext art (the open-source, copyleft cult of Lialina)

Lialina's original frameset version of the work:

  • Modularity = constriction

  • Linking = the opposite of expansiveness and freedom: exhaustion and imprisonment
Previous lecture section Next lecture section

Previous lecture section

References

 

Previous lecture section