layer hidden off the screen
UCSB English Department HomeUCSB English Department HomeUCSB English Department Home
 
 
The Culture of Information
ENGL 25 — Winter 2002, Alan Liu
Notes for Class 11

This page contains materials intended to facilitate class discussion (excerpts from readings, outlines of issues, links to resources, etc.). The materials are not necessarily the same as the instructor's teaching notes and are not designed to represent a full exposition or argument. This page is subject to revision as the instructor finalizes preparation. (Last revised 2/4/02 )



Preliminary Class Business

  • (Monday) Class 12: Interactive Discussion on "New Media" and "New Media Art"
  • Four-page paper due in lecture in Class 12
  • Reading Exam 1 in Class 13, Feb. 6th
    • Short-answer questions
    • Multiple-choice questions
    • Identification questions
  • Students with problems installing Riven on their computers
 Next lecture section


Previous lecture section Next lecture section

Overview of Hypertext and Hypertext Literature

"Hypertext" was one of the first deployments of "new media" principles (digitization, modularity, variability).

  • Practical Hypertext: from "Gopher" (U. Minnesota) to "WWW" (Tim Berners-Lee; NCSA and Mosaic browser)

  • Conceptual & Artistic Exploration of Hypertext: (e.g., George Landow, p. 100 [in Trend]:
A Timeline of Hypertext Theory/Literature
For a more detailed chronology, see Stuart Moulthrop, "A Subjective Chronology of Literary Hypertext" (Other UCSB English Dept. courses on hypertext: Rita Raley, English 165LT, Alan Liu, English 165HL)

1940-50's -------------> 1970 -------------> 1980 -------------> 1990 -------------> 2000

WW II, Transition from Modernism to "Postmodernism"

Counterculture, Poststructuralism, Personal Computer Beginning of Hypertext Theory & Practice WWW
Bush, Borges Barthes, Derrida, Foucault, Deleuze & Guattari

Ted Nelson Michael Joyce
Jay Bolter
George Landow
J. Yellowlees Douglas
Stuart Moulthrop
Storyspace
Eastgate Inc.
                  M. D. Coverley
Previous lecture section Next lecture section


Previous lecture section Next lecture section

Critical Issues of Hypertext (as exemplified in Edward Falco's "Self-Portrait as Child with Father")

"Self-Portrait as Child with Father" is a work that tries to show that "new media" is not either more clear or more obscure, but clear and obscure in different ways that can be exploited to map out what is important to people.

The obscurity in Falco's work demonstrates some of the standard, much-discussed "problematics" of hypertext literature):

The Problem of Navigation

Ever onward, or hub-and-spoke navigation?

Does one return and reread previously read lexia?

Does one's pattern of reading the work evolve or change?

What is the effect of chance on the reading experience?


The Problem of Closure

How is a sense of closure achieved by the reader?

  • closure = completion (hitting all the "lexia" or reading units)?

  • closure = mapping (systematic sense of the whole)? (analogy of a XML document)

  • or is closure needed at all?

The Problem of Narrative

Is this work a "story," or a "description" or perhaps "lyric"? [blocks.html] [figs.html] [jumped.html] [snow.html]


The Problem of Point-of-View

Who is speaking in children.html or beggar.html or quiet.html?

Why is this work a "self-portrait" of the child and not a "portrait" of the father? [child.html]


The Problem of Interactivity (Role of the "Reader")

Is the reader empowered as an "author" or co-author? (Cf., Landow)

Or is the interactivity just a sham, just another way of controlling the reader?

Previous lecture section Next lecture section


Previous lecture section Next lecture section

Olia Lialina's My Boyfriend Came Back From the War (1996)

Lialina's influence on new-media/hypertext art (the open-source, copyleft cult of Lialina)

Lialina's original frameset version of Boyfriend:

  • A "hypermedia" version of hypertext (images, graphic design and typography, framesets, and animation/sound in later "covers" of the work by others)

  • Equivalent "problematics" of navigation, closure, narrative, point of view, sentence form, interactivity.

  • Lialina's specific deployment of the principles of new media underlying these problematics:

    • Digital Modularity = constriction of human relationships

    • Linking = the opposite of expansiveness, freedom, and connection: exhaustion, imprisonment, disconnection
Previous lecture section Next lecture section


Previous lecture section Next lecture section

New Media Art:
The Case of New Graphic Design
("Graphic Design" = Graphics + Typography + Layout)

Example of contemporary, mainstream graphic design (from advertising):

Chanel "Allure" Ad, 1999 Chanel ad from Wired 7.09, Sept. 1999
(9 x 10.75")
Previous lecture section Next lecture section


Previous lecture section Next lecture section

Where the Allure of Mainstream Graphic Design Came From (A Short History)

19th-Century Typographic Design

1888 Poster Showing Principles of 19th-C. Graphic Design


Avant-Garde Typographic Experimentation
(see Johanna Drucker, The Visible Word)

F.T. Marinetti, from Zang Tumb Tuuum (Milan, 1914)


F.T. Marinetti, from Zang Tumb Tuuum (Milan, 1914)
F.T. Marinetti, "Bataille a neuf etages: Mont Altissimo (Rome, 1916)

F.T. Marinetti, Bataille à neuf étages: Mont Altissimo (Rome, 1916)
I. Zdanevich, "Soiree du Coeur a Barbe" (Paris, 1923)

I. Zdanevich, Soirée du Coeur à Barbe (Paris, 1923)
T. Tzara, "Bulletin" (Zurich, 1918)


T. Tzara, Bulletin (Zurich, 1918)
  • Main Features:

    • Assymmetrical layout
    • Use of diagonals in layout
    • Designed use of white space
    • Emphasis on contrasting elements

  • Goals: Intended to shock the bourgeois (and its concept of art as "high culture"); mimetic of the WW I-era sense of culture

The Professionalization/Mainstreaming of Avant-Garde Graphic Design Principles (see Jan Tschichold, The New Typography, 1928; excerpts):

arrow down
arrow down
El Lissitzky, Two pages (poem titles) from Mayakovsky (1922-23)


El Lissitzky, Two pages (poem titles) from Mayakovsky, Diya golossa (1922-23) (reproduced in Tschichold)
Piet Zwart, from advertising leaflet

Piet Zwart, from advertising leaflet (original in Dutch) (reproduced in Tschichold)
Jan Tschichold, poster and cover Jan Tschichold, display poster for publisher, 1924 (l.), and cover for "elementaire typographie, 1925 (r.)
Willi Baumeister, invitation card Willi Baumeister, invitation card (example of "reading order" reproduced in Tschichold)
Jan Tschihold, example of bad layout Jan Tschichold, example of good layout
Jan Tschichold, examples of bad and good layout from The New Typography
Jan Tschichold, brochure for "The New Typography"



Jan Tschichold, brochure for The New Typography

Goals:
  • Informational "clarity" (quote 1 | 2) (a version of the Modernist credo of "form follows function"

  • The naturalization of the look-and-feel of avant-garde design (cf., Manovitch on the "anti-montage" tendencies of contemporary "compositing")

  • Corporate style: Swiss Style, International Style
    (migration of European designers after WW II; the Container Corporation of America)



Thus was born the "look and feel" of contemporary corporate graphic design: a "designed" form of immediacy:

Chanel "Allure" Ad, 1999 Chanel ad from Wired 7.09, Sept. 1999
(9 x 10.75")
Previous lecture section Next lecture section


Previous lecture section Next lecture section

New Media Graphic Design (Anti-Design)


Goals:

  • Unclarity

  • Denaturalization of the look-and-feel of avant-garde design (aggressive montage vs. compositing)

    • assymmetry to the nth degree
    • "grids" used ironically (example)
    • hybrid, "bleeding," or "distressed" fonts and images (as opposed to sans serif) (example)

  • Exposure of the underlying principles of digital new media:
    • digitization (e.g., Greiman's "jaggie" fonts)
    • modularity (retro photo-montage)

  • Reflection of "postmodern" or "postindustrial" age

[To next class notes]

Previous lecture section Next lecture section

Previous lecture section

References

  • Johanna Drucker, The Visible Word: Experimental Typography and Modern Art, 1909-1923 (Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press, 1994)
  • Edward Falco, "Typing with Edward Falco" (interview with Falco) (Blue Penny Quarterly, 1996)
  • Philip B. Meggs, A History of Graphic Design, 2d ed. (New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1983)
  • Paul Rand, A Designer's Art (New Haven: Yale Univ. Press, 1985)
  • Darrell Sano, Designing Large-Scale Web Sites: A Visual Design Methodology (New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1996)
Previous lecture section